[Currently showing in the Cleveland area only at the Cedar Lee theater]
Review by Bob Ignizio
None of us really knows how much time we'll have on this earth, or what course our lives will take. Not so the children of Halisham Hall. They know they've got about 30 years at best, and that their purpose in life is to donate organs so that others may live longer, healthier lives. They don't really understand what this means at first. Even after a teacher tries to spell it out for them plainly, it's unclear if the reality of their situation fully sinks in. Even as teenagers, they still seem to act as if they'll live forever. But then isn't that always the case with teenagers? Hell, isn't that the case for most of us even long after we're past our teenage years?
Review by Bob Ignizio
None of us really knows how much time we'll have on this earth, or what course our lives will take. Not so the children of Halisham Hall. They know they've got about 30 years at best, and that their purpose in life is to donate organs so that others may live longer, healthier lives. They don't really understand what this means at first. Even after a teacher tries to spell it out for them plainly, it's unclear if the reality of their situation fully sinks in. Even as teenagers, they still seem to act as if they'll live forever. But then isn't that always the case with teenagers? Hell, isn't that the case for most of us even long after we're past our teenage years?
Never Let Me Go is a subtle, melancholy film about the human tendency to deny our own mortality until it is staring us right in the face. When the realization suddenly hits us, we beg the universe for just a little more time, bemoaning the mistakes we've made in the past. Kathy (Carey Mulligan) and Tommy (Andrew Garfield) want a deferment of the inevitable because they missed their chance at love when they were young. Ruth (Keira Knightley) wants to make ammends for coming between the two. These characters certainly seem deserving, but since when has that ever had anything to do with the way the world works?
Although it's not obvoius at first, this is a science fiction film. The film takes place in an alternate timeline where human cloning was discovered in the early fifties, allowing “normal” humans to extend their lifespans by replacing worn out parts from the clones. Maybe it seems far fetched that people would just accept the killing of these clones. All I can say is, the human race has done as bad if not worse for far less in the past, and found ways to rationalize it. There are certianly interesting moral questions raised by this notion, but not what this film is concerned with.
That said, perhaps a little more information about the way the outside world reacted to cloning would have been nice. It definitely would have helped if the film made it clearer why the clones were so accepting of their lot. I haven't read the book by Kazuo Ishiguro, but I did hear an interview with him and director Mark Romanek in which it was mentioned these characters see themselves as fulfilling a noble cause. We don't get any sense of that in the film version, and I think it suffers because of it. Still, this is a very well made, well acted movie with some intriguing themes. 3 ½ out of 4 stars.
Rated R
Rated R

A non-science fiction science-fiction movie? I think you nailed it on the themes. Now I want to read the book.
ReplyDelete