Holly (Katherine Heigl) and Messer (Josh Duhamel) don't much like each other. The only thing they have in common is their friendship with the Novaks, a married couple who have just had their first baby, Sophie. Tragically, the Novaks both die in a car accident. In their will, they name Holly and Messer as Sophie's guardians. That should be the recipe for yet another unfunny and formulaic romantic comedy. Formula it certainly is, but at least as far as laughs are concerned, there's a fair number to be had.
Movies like this tend to test my suspension of disbelief even more than overt fantasy films. The universe they exist in resembles the real world to some degree, and to all appearances the characters are human beings. But I find there's usually more recognizably human qualities in your average hobbit or talking owl than you're likely to find in the lead characters of a Hollywood romantic comedy. That's not the case here. Thanks to the performances of Heigl and Duhamel, these stock characters remain believable even when the movie itself isn't. That goes a long way towards keeping audience good will even as the film races to its obvious and cliched conclusion.
As predictable as the script is, writers Ian Deitchman and Kristin Rusk Robinson deserve some credit not just for their jokes, but for a handful of character moments that feel genuine. Director Greg Berlantie also deserves props for the restrained tone of the film. So many romantic comedies feel like really long episodes of a bad sitcom, so it's nice to see one that treats its audience like adults who possess a reasonable attention span. 3 out of 4 stars.

That's pretty fair, given this type of movie.
ReplyDelete