Review by Pamela Zoslov
Whenever I see a movie like It’s Kind of a Funny Story, about yet another
This movie’s Holden is Craig (Keir Gilchrist), a student at the competitive
The movie opens with a dream sequence in which Craig is preparing to ride his bike off the
Craig is mentored by Bobby (Zach Galifianakis, of The Hangover fame), a suicidal slacker who dispenses bits of recycled wisdom when not posing as a doctor or playing table tennis (he abhors the word “ping-pong.”). Bobby is one of a diverse mix of patients on the ward, a multicultural group portrayed with various forms of condescension. There’s a Hasidic Jew who flipped out on acid, a black woman professor-turned-paranoid schizophrenic, and Craig’s Egyptian roommate Muqtada, who refuses to leave his room. There is also Noelle (Emma Roberts), a stunning, sardonic teenage girl sporting suicidal scars (even, curiously, on her cheek). Craig likes to draw architectural abstracts, and Noelle helps him find his inner artist. His budding relationship with Noelle also helps him forge a pathway to mental health—not that long a trip, actually.
Realistic the story is not. And yet it is based on the real experiences of Ned Vizzini, a young-adult novelist whose autobiographical first novel was adapted by Anna Boden and Ryan Fleck, who also directed. Whatever wit the book contained is largely absent from the movie, which has a tendency to apologize repeatedly for its own triviality. Ultimately, Craig realizes that his troubles, compared to the desperate problems of the other patients, don’t amount to very much, and that makes the movie less than profound. And, although it’s not spelled out in the movie, the class differences between wealthy Craig and his co-patients are never far from consciousness. When rumpled Bobby needs to look presentable to interview for a place at a group home, Craig has merely to phone Dad for a crisp
Galifianakis, who is the main reason to see the movie, is amusing and rather touching as the troubled slacker who covers his suffering with a veneer of nonchalance. But the movie doesn’t allow Galifianakis, or anyone, to be funny or interesting enough, relying instead on a surfeit of whimsical fantasy sequences. Most emblematic of this tendency is a scene in which Craig reluctantly stands up to sing in front of a music therapy class. Instead of showing us Zach’s shy, tentative musical efforts, the movie cuts to an elaborately staged music video, with the other patients backing up spandex-clad Craig, all lip-syncing to a recording of the Queen/David Bowie song “Under Pressure.” Gimmicks like these, aimed at young audiences weaned on music videos, sadly detract from what should have been a touching human story.
It seems unfair that a movie with such potential does it half-assed. In many ways, that's worse than any trashy B-movie.
ReplyDelete