Friday, December 17, 2010

How Do You Know

Review by Pamela Zoslov
It’s been a long time since we encountered the eccentric style of James L. Brooks on the big screen – his last major film (unless you count Spanglish), was As Good As It Gets in 1997. The multiple Emmy and Oscar-winning writer, director, actor and producer, whose credits span television’s top tier (The Mary Tyler Moore Show, Taxi, The Simpsons), is not a prolific filmmaker, having made only six movies in 27 years. Brooks has described filmmaking as “lonely,” which may explain why he doesn’t do it often.

Brooks’ reticence is reflected in his movies, which are all about talking and not talking. The characters in his new romantic comedy, How Do You Know, are forever telling each other not to say anything, calling to say they’re not calling, walking away from a conversation, or berating themselves for saying things they regret. In a sense, Brooks’ dialogue is about the importance, and the peril, of words – a metaphor, perhaps, for the writing process, with its frustrating blocks and endless revisions. In a Brooks romantic comedy, there’s a lot more thinking, talking and explaining than lovemaking.

The story centers on two people going through a rough patch in life. Lisa (Reese Witherspoon), a 31-year-old softball player, has been cut from the U.S. team, leading her to intensify an ill-considered relationship with affable but self-centered Washington Nationals pitcher Matty (Owen Wilson). George (Paul Rudd), a likable business executive, is facing prosecution for securities fraud, the result of shady manipulations by his rich, bombastic father, Charles (Jack Nicholson, rather raspy of voice). Their lives momentarily in shambles, Lisa and George stumble into a blind date. Both are so overwrought that Lisa insists they eat dinner in total silence. Charmed by her unusual approach, George consoles himself with thoughts of Lisa while avoiding dealing with his upcoming federal indictment. At the same time, Lisa deals with the casual inconsideration of her athlete boyfriend, a womanizer who keeps a drawer full of new toothbrushes and a wardrobe stacked with pink track suits for his many one-night stands.

The movie has little interest in Lisa’s sports career or the details of George’s case, a potentially interesting theme at a time when financial malfeasance is convulsing the nation. Lisa responds to the death of her athletic ambitions by going full-bore into a relationship, a life path she explicitly opposes (“I always think they’re pretending,” she says of women who say they’re happy choosing marriage and babies over career). George sells nearly everything he has to hire an expensive lawyer, but for some reason, learns about his legal options from his shouty, grandstanding dad, who presents him with a Hobson’s choice: plead guilty and spend a few years in jail, or allow them to send Dad, a repeat offender, to jail for the rest of his life. If ever anyone needed some good legal advice, it’s this guy.

The screenplay makes George pleasantly bland, with only a few distinctive traits – a penchant for Teddy Pendergrass, a specialty drink he invented when he was a bartender, and a highly unlikely biographical detail: his mom left his dad after seeing Kramer v. Kramer. Lisa has even less personal history than that.
This long and shapeless movie never quite coalesces, but it does contain some memorably quirky scenes, like the maternity-ward marriage proposal stammered out by the boyfriend of new mom Annie (Kathryn Hahn), George’s loyal secretary. The scene is Brooks at his best, blending pathos and comedy in strange ways: when George fails to capture the proposal on video, everyone in the room has to scramble to reconstruct the dialogue. Again, it’s all about words.

Because the story is less than satisfying, a lot depends on the performers. Witherspoon’s character is “hard,” like Brooks heroines Debra Winger in Terms of Endearment, Holly Hunter in Broadcast News and Helen Hunt in As Good As It Gets, which makes Lisa believable as an athlete, less so as an inspiring love object. Rudd, who I think is less effective in serious roles than in Judd Apatow comedies, is the quintessential “nice guy,” painted as a loser despite his obvious appeal (only in Movieland!). Wilson, the go-to actor for affable Golden Retriever-type guys, has more to work with. Brooks gives Matty some of the best lines, which have him forever explaining and analyzing, in his shallow but sincere way, his approach to relationships, including the insight that gives the movie its title. “How do you know when you’re in love?” Matty asks his teammates. The answer that rings his bell: “When I wear a condom with the other girls." 2 stars out of 4.

No comments:

Post a Comment

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.