Monday, November 1, 2010

Mr. Hulot's Holiday (November 4th and 6th at the Cleveland Cinematheque)

[Mr. Hulot's Holiday screens Thursday November 4th at 7pm and Saturday November 6th at 5:15 pm at the Cleveland Cinematheque.]

Review by Charles Cassady, Jr.

French filmmaker-comic Jacques Tati scored an international hit in 1953, scooping up the Grand Prize at Cannes among other accolades, for this disjointed, mostly nonverbal comedy that established a character he would come to play over and over again. Monsieur Hulot is a lanky, pipe-smoking bachelor gent, usually in a long raincoat, who heads to the coast of Brittany for a beachside vacation. There he innocently causes (or strolls obliviously into) one mishap after another at a seaside resort. His unfashionable vintage 1924 auto gets forced off the road by a flashy American car (those were the days, *sigh*); he accidentally triggers an argument among card players; his kayak weirdly breaks in two and somehow comes to resemble a snapping, toothy sea beast that scares everyone out of the water. In a running gag, any time Hulot realizes some disaster is more or less his fault, he dashes to his cabin, shuts the door and peeks sheepishly out the window (ya know, if a guy like Hulot were around in real life today he'd probably be diagnosed with adult autism and be forced to wear a padded helmet and ride the short bus. Probably to a cushy government job, too. Sorry, I have issues.). Throughout, Hulot is attracted to a girl at the hotel but is too shy to approach her. And even that makes the movie sound more tightly plotted than it is.
International movie buffs cherish Les Vacances de Monsieur Hulot for its deft slapstick (and, I suspect, being a wholesome, non-threatening, crossover comedy in an era when a lot of pictures hailing from Europe were angry, Bicycle Thief-type outcries of pain and injustice with Marxist political agendas). Still, the slack tendency of the non-storyline to just ramble on from bit to bit gets a touch dull in the long run. It's worth noting that during his long career Tati only finished a handful of feature films - most of which starred him returning as Hulot. His careful planning and staging each gag and building costly trick sets to accommodate his vision took him up to five years per picture. Even today, watching this, one admires the care and attention to detail that went into setting up the gags.

For what it's worth, the recent Mr. Bean's Holiday, Rowan Atkinson's alleged swan song for his similarly nonverbal character, is in many aspects a tribute to Mr. Hulot's Holiday. Call me a blasphemer, a Philistine, a yankee-capitalist imperialist pig-dog, but I liked Mr. Bean's vacation better and still mourn that it wasn't as much of a hit among 2007 US audiences as was Hulot's leisurely debut 54 years previously. 

1 comment:

  1. "Leisurely humor" is something, I think, only the French could produce. And thank you for answering my Mr. Bean question that was forming in my head as I read this review.

    ReplyDelete

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.