Showing posts with label Straw Dogs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Straw Dogs. Show all posts

Friday, September 16, 2011

Straw Dogs

Review by Matt Finley

One of the most divisive films of the early ‘70s, Sam Peckinpah’s STRAW DOGS drew battle lines between two sets of film critics: those who saw the tale of a nebbish creampuff driven to violent extremes in the name of his family and home as a compelling exploration of man’s innate violence and the mutability of society’s civilized ideal, and those who thought it was a gratuitously misogynistic rape-fest ending in a tiresomely over-indulgent celebration of vengeful brutality (and a lousy Peckinpah film to boot). I mention this critics divide because director Rod Lurie (THE CONTENDER) started his film career as a critic. Though he was too young in ’71 to throw his hat into the original debate, his 2011 STRAW DOGS remake, which he both directed and wrote, is nothing if not utterly intent on convincing the viewer that Peckinpah’s original vision was pure brilliance… the themes, he seems to insist, just needed a bit more emphasis.

The result? whereas Peckinpah hit the audience over the head with a sledgehammer (movie-wise… in person, he used guns), Lurie hits us with a giant Acme-brand anvil.