[A HEN IN THE WIND
screens Saturday May 4th at 5:15 pm and Sunday May 5th at 6:30 pm
at the Cleveland Cinematheque.]
Review
by Bob Ignizio
In
post-World Warr II Japan, sometimes people have to make difficult
choices to get by. Tokiko (Kinuyo Tanaka) is faced with just such a
choice when her 4 year old son Hiroshi becomes sick. The boy gets
better, but Tokiko is left with a sizable doctor's bill to pay. With
her husband still not returned from the war, and all her valuable
possessions already sold, Tokiko sees no alternative but to
prostitute herself for the money.
When
Tokiko tells her friend Akiko (Chieko Murata) what she did, she is
somewhat surprised at how harshly she gets chastised. After all,
earlier in the film Akiko had said that, “she would sell her soul”
if she had a child who needed anything. When Tokiko's husband Shuichi
(Shūji Sano) finally returns, things appear to be looking up for
Tokiko. However, when Shuichi asks his wife how she managed to pay
their son's medical bills, the woman cannot bring herself to lie to
the man she has always been honest with. Again she is surprised by
how harshly she is reproached for doing what she felt she had to do.
Director
Yasujiro Ozu may not be surprised by the negative reactions his
protagonist gets, but he is clearly in sympathy with her. This is
obviously a film that deals with what would have been a real issue in
Japan at the time, namely the ways that war widows and those still
waiting for their husbands to be repatriated had to get by in the
period immediately following the end of World War II. However, it
could apply to any situation where someone has to make a difficult,
perhaps personally humiliating choice out of necessity.
This
was my first exposure to the films of Ozu, and while it is not one of
the films generally trotted out as among his classics, it nonetheless
displays his trademarks as a director: His camera is generally placed
very low, barely off the ground. He has tendency to transition
between shots by cutting to shots of locations and objects. There is
a tendency not to show certain major events – in this case, we
don't actually see Tokiko working at the brothel, but hear about it
from her John afterwards. All these things were innovations at the
time Ozu first did them, and his films still stand out as looking
very different from even most arthouse films today.
What
could easily have been an overly melodramatic plot is tempered by the
believable characters and a couple of interesting subplots involving
Tokiko's husband. In one, he goes to the brothel himself and meets
another working girl. He finds it far easier to feel sympathy for
this woman than he does for his own wife. He also discusses his
problems with a friend who serves as sort of a voice of reason,
albeit one that Shuichi doesn't necessarily listen to.
That
HEN IN THE WIND isn't
regarded as the masterpiece that many of Ozu's films are isn't
surprising after seeing it. It's a good film, but ultimately feels
like a lesser work from a great talent. It's also a film that can be
difficult for modern viewers. Ozu may sympathize with his heroine and
recognize her strength, but there's something that Shuichi does to
Tokiko near the end of the film that makes it hard to root for this
couple to get back together as the filmmaker seems to want us to.
Different times, different cultures I suppose. But hey, who says a
movie has to be perfectly in tune with modern western liberal
sensibilities in order to be worth watching? Certainly not this
critic. 3 out of 4 stars.

No comments:
Post a Comment
We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.