[OSCAR NOMINATED LIVE ACTION SHORTS and OSCAR NOMINATED ANIMATED SHORTS open in Cleveland on Friday February 11th exclusively at the Cedar Lee Theater.]
Review by Bob Ignizio
Every year the Academy Awards gives out a statue for “Short Film (Live Action)” and “Short Film (Animated)”. These are films most of us don't get the chance to see, since the days when movie theaters actually showed short films along with the features are long gone. But for the last few years, select theaters have been showing the nominated shorts in special programs, one each for Live Action and Animated. In Cleveland, the shorts will be screening at the Cedar Lee Theater starting Friday, February 11th.
OSCAR NOMINATED LIVE ACTION SHORTS
In Tanel Toom's The Confession, two young boys are preparing for their first experience with the titular ritual. They laugh and make light of it, but one of them is worried he won't have anything to confess, and therefore won't be a real Catholic. Then things take a dark turn into near horror territory. It feels almost like a Jack Ketchum (The Girl Next Door, The Lost) novel. It's effectively disturbing, with great performances by the two young leads.
Also dealing with kids in a somewhat disturbing light is Michael Creagh's The Crush. Creagh's short concerns the age old predicament of schoolboys having the hots for their teachers. It's played lightly and for laughs, but considering the lengths the young student goes to in trying to get his teacher to dump her loser boyfriend, maybe it should have been handled with a little more seriousness.
Wish 143 has a premise that sounds like it could have been a Saturday Night Live skit. A teenage boy dying of cancer asks a “Make a Wish” type organization to help him achieve his dream. What does he want? To have sex with a woman. But director Ian Barnes handles the material deftly, and by the end he's crafted a tale with genuine pathos.
In God of Love, the unlucky in love Ray (writer/director Luke Matheny) receives a mysterious box of darts that can make anyone stuck with them fall in love with whoever they see at the time of sticking for 6 hours. In some cases, this may lead to a lasting relationship. Shot in black and white, and with such self consciously quirky conceits as Ray making a living by crooning while throwing darts, this short is just too cutesy for its own good.
Set during the recent period of ethnic cleansing in Rwanda, Na We We points out the absurdity of trying to create racial divisions in a modern, multi-cultural world where race and nationality aren't always so clear. The short walks a fine line here, as going just the slightest bit too far in the wrong direction could be seen as making light of a very serious situation. I think director/co-writer Ivan Goldschmitt manages to avoid that, but in the end the short feels more concerned with delivering its punchline than in being a real, meaningful look at its subject.
OSCAR NOMINATED ANIMATED SHORTS
Once upon a time, just about every major studio had an animation department churning out shorts. It was the golden age of Looney Toons, Tom and Jerry, and Walt Disney. Pixar still makes the occasional short film to go along with their features, and last year's horrendous CATS AND DOGS 2: THE REVENGE OF KITTY GALORE came with a new Road Runner cartoon. In general, though, animated shorts are still a rare breed in theaters.
Day and Night is one of those aforementioned Pixar shorts. Although it still utilizes some of the company's trademark computer animation, Day and Night's two primary characters appear to be drawn rather than conjured up by a machine. It's a typically clever and funny Pixar short that has a good chance of winning the company yet another statute.
The CGI animals of The Gruffalo are given voice by some high profile talent, including Helena Bonham Carter and Tom Wilkinson. It's basically your classic childrens' story with a moral, and as such is cute and entertaining enough. The animation is fine, with the character design looking more ICE AGE than Pixar, but nothing mind-blowing.
Looking like some lost fifties public service short, Let's Pollute is a well meaning but heavy-handed would-be satire with an environmental message. The problem is, even the most biting satire is still supposed to be funny, and this really isn't. I do like the old-school approach to the animation, though. The short has a nice cheap but still visually interesting look, like an old Bullwinkle or Underdog cartoon.
The Lost Thing is an imaginatively designed bit of CGI weirdness, but ultimately not that satisfying in the story department. And finally, Madagascar: A Journey Diary is the most visually interesting and experimental of the nominated shorts. It comes off feeling a bit like it was produced by the Madagascar tourism bureau, but it's nonetheless a fine film.
The program of animated shorts is filled out with the addition of two films that aren't nominated. Bill Plymton's The Cow Who Wanted to be a Hamburger is typically twisted Plympton, and in my opinion more deserving of recognition than some of the actual nominees. Urs also feels like it should have been in the final five. My guess is it was a little too downbeat for the voters, but at least it gets to be seen alongside the official nominees in this program.
All things averaged out, I'd say both of these programs are in the 3 out of 4 stars range, with each containing at least one 4 star short and no total duds. Get out and see them while you can.




No comments:
Post a Comment
We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.