Review by Pamela Zoslov
For underneath her borders, the devil draws no lines,
If you drag her muddy river, nameless bodies you will find,
Whoa, the fat trees of the forest have hid a thousand crimes,
The calendar is lyin’ when it reads the present time
Whoa, here’s to the land you’ve torn out the heart of,
Mississippi find yourself another country to be part of!
(Phil Ochs)
The long and murderous history of the struggle for civil rights in America haunts us still, its horrifying images seared with sorrow into our memories. The body of Emmett Till, the friendly 14-year-old boy lynched while visiting relatives in Mississippi, lying in his casket, open at the insistence of his grieving mother so the world could see what they did to her boy. The faces on a “Missing” poster of three young civil right workers, Andrew Goodman, James Chaney and Michael Schwerner, kidnapped in the night by Klansmen on June 21, 1964, their bodies found six weeks later buried in an earthen dam. Goodman and Schwerner had been shot to death, but the greatest savagery was reserved for Chaney, a black man. He was beaten, tortured and buried alive, while his little brother waited for him to come home and teach him to ride a bike.
The case, best known to later generations as the subject of the 1988 movie MISSISSIPPI BURNING, inspired Phil Ochs’ bitter, heartfelt cri de coeur “Here’s To the State of Mississippi,” which urged the state to leave the union. Nina Simone denounced the state in her angry anthem “Mississippi Goddam.” Of all the Southern states where racist atrocities occurred, Mississippi seemed the worst, the place that condoned the murders of Emmett Till, Goodman, Chaney and Schwerner, civil rights leader Medgar Evers, and countless unnamed black men whose corpses lay underground or in the Mississippi River, their families bereft but their killers never pursued.
The documentary NESHOBA: THE PRICE OF FREEDOM, directed by Micki Dickoff and Tony Pagano, centers on the efforts of residents of present-day Neshoba, County, Mississippi, to come to terms with the terrible legacy of the murders of Goodman, Chaney and Schwerner, and to either bury the past, as some residents would like, or bring someone to justice for the crime after the state, in the grips of corruption that comprised the Klan, the cops, the governor, and J. Edgar Hoover and the federal government, allowed most of them to walk free.
Juxtaposing archival and contemporary footage, the film recounts the 1964 case in all its horrifying detail and aftermath. The six-week search for the three missing young men. The national alarm at the trio’s disappearance, which owed largely to the fact that two of them were white, and which was dismissed by local officials as a “publicity hoax.” (Sheriff Lawrence Rainey had scoffed to reporters, “If they’re in Mississippi, they’re just hiding out somewhere and trying to get a lot of publicity out of it.”)
The discovery of the bodies, and the refusal of Mississippi officials to prosecute the killers for murder, a state crime. The federal government’s trial of 18 men, including Sheriff Rainey and Deputy Sheriff Cecil Price, for violating the three victims’ civil rights, a federal crime. Seven were found guilty, receiving sentences of three to ten years; none served more than six years. The wrenching grief of the victims’ families, then and today – Chaney’s siblings and elderly mother, Goodman’s parents and brother, Shwerner’s politically committed widow, Rita Bender. Autopsy photos of the brutalized victims. And, perhaps most wrenching of all, footage from the funeral of Chaney, the only Mississippian of the three, where mourners sang “We Shall Overcome” and the sight of Chaney’s little brother’s tear-stained face led Dave Dennis, the Mississippi director of the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE), to deliver an angry, fiery eulogy.
One of the defendants in the federal trial was Edgar Ray Killen, a Baptist preacher, sawmill operator and Klan official strongly implicated in the murders. He was acquitted because a lone juror said she “could never convict a preacher.” Killen was indicted in 2005 for the murders after investigative journalist Jerry Mitchell of the Jackson Clarion-Ledger, whose persistence helped secure convictions in other high-profile civil rights murder cases, developed new evidence with a group of students, including taped interviews with Killen, that pressured the state to reopen the case. NESHOBA documents the efforts of a multiracial citizens’ council in Philadelphia, Mississippi, that issued a call for justice.
Killen, an unregenerate racist 80 years old at the time of filming, reflects on the campaign to make him “a scapegoat” for the murders, confident he will not be convicted. (The film acknowledges that Killen was an easy target, and that many other known conspirators, still living, were not charged.) The filmmakers travel to the all-white Neshoba County Fair, where heavyset residents opine about the reopened case. “Let sleeping dogs lie,” says one. “Leave it alone. What good will it do?” Other locals feel acutely that the wound will not be healed until there is justice. “How the hell can we live in Mississippi with a history like that?”
The ornery Killen, in a wheelchair as the result of a logging accident, protests his innocence but shares some of his racial philosophy, a reminder of the still active ideas that governed the Southern segregationist ethos. Race-mixing, Killen lectures, is Communism, and those promoting equality “wanted to live like the blacks…most of ’em was as immoral as you could imagine.” Articulating the inarticulate views of many at the time and some even today, Killen opines that the victims were responsible for their own deaths. They were Jews, Communists, telling Southerners how to live, even recruiting black men to rape white women. “If those three had stayed home where they belonged,” Killen asserts, “they would never have found any harm.”
The film takes us inside the dramatic trial, covered by international media and attended by the families of the murdered men. “I want to see some justice done before I leave this world,” says Fannie Lee Chaney, the frail but determined mother of James Chaney, who is helped up the courthouse steps by her surviving children.
Mrs. Chaney has since left this world, but she lived to see some measure of justice -- too little and too late, yes, delayed but not denied. By the trial’s end, some healing has begun for contemporary Mississippians over the state’s shameful past, though the film emphasizes that many of the guilty have not paid, and never will, for the crimes that shocked the conscience of the world. 4 stars out of 4.

No comments:
Post a Comment
We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.