Monday, January 17, 2011

Who is Harry Nilsson? (January 19th at the Cleveland Museum of Art)

[WHO IS HARRY NILSSON? Screens Wednesday January 19th at 6:45pm at the Cleveland Museum of Art Morley Lecture Hall.]

Review by Bob Ignizio

To be honest, I had to ask myself who Harry Nilsson was. I was vaguely aware that Nilsson was a singer who had a few hits in the seventies, but I just couldn't place him. Of course as soon as I started watching the movie, I was like, “oh yeah, he's that guy!” The guy who sang “Everybody's Talkin'” aka the song from MIDNIGHT COWBOY. The guy who wrote and sang “Coconut” (“You put de lime in de coconut and drink em both up.”). The guy who wrote “One”, a huge hit for Three Dog Night. The guy who formed a mutual admiration society with the Beatles and worked on projects with both John and Ringo (and partied with them, too). How could someone like that be so easily forgotten? Probably because Nilsson went out of his way to be the anti-rock star.

To say Nilsson had an odd career path would be an understatement. Although he wrote hits for other artists, two of his three biggest hits as a recording artist himself were covers (“Everybody's Talkin'” and “Without You”). He followed his biggest critical and commercial success (the Nilsson Schmilsson album) with an aggressively noncommercial record filled with catchy but profanity-laced songs that would never get played on the radio. Other odd choices included an album of all Randy Newman covers (when no one even knew who Randy Newman was) and an album of old standards long before that became the “in” thing to do. On top of that, Nilsson never played concerts. And yet somehow he managed to have a fairly successful career. His personal life was another matter entirely.

John Scheinfeld's documentary paints a portrait of an intensely private and guarded artist. You get the feeling that even Harry's closest friends and relatives didn't get much past the surface. It's suggested that, where many artists might take their personal pain and exorcise it by using it in their work, Harry tended to keep his inside. Of course we get a lot of the usual VH1 Behind the Music type of stuff – tempestuous love life, lots of booze and drugs – and as usual, some of the rock & roll war stories are entertaining. But by the end of this 2 hour documentary, we're still not much closer to answering the film's titular question than we were at the beginning. That's not to say that the time is wasted, or that Scheinfeld didn't try his best, but Nilsson remains as enigmatic as his music. 3 out of 4 stars.

1 comment:

  1. Looking forward to this and will probably pick up the DVD, too. I was never a big Nilsson fan, but was aware of his status as a subversive, original songwriter and killer singer for THE POINT and other stuff. My family sings several of his tunes 'round the campfire every summer--including some of those old standards he covered in the late 70s. Good write-up! CANT LIIIIIIVE CANT GIVE ANYMORE!!

    ReplyDelete

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.