[NINE NATION ANIMATION screens Friday January 28th at 7:00pm and Saturday January 29th at 1:30pm at the Cleveland Museum of Art Morley Lecture Hall]
Review by Bob Ignizio
Mainstream animated features tend to get stuck in stylistic ruts. For decades, the medium was dominated by the Disney style as exemplified by SNOW WHITE AND THE SEVEN DWARFS. With the advent of computer animation, Pixar has become the new standard. Regardless of how creative the stories might be, both Pixar and its competitors are all putting out movies that follow in the stylistic footsteps of TOY STORY and FINDING NEMO, which frankly, aren't that far removed from the Disney archetypes that preceded them. Well, you won't find anything even close to Disney or Pixar in NINE NATION ANIMATION, a collection of 9 animated shorts from around the world that make use of a multitude of animation styles and techniques. For those worried about subtitles, only 3 of the 9 shorts require them, one of which is in cat and mouse language and would need translation in any country. The rest are either in English or devoid of dialogue.
The anthology opens with Norway's “Deconstruction Workers”, a darkly humorous short by Kajsa Naess which uses a style similar to Terry Gilliam's cut-out animation from Monty Python's Flying Circus mixed with a little live action. An older construction worker explains to his younger counterpart that it's natural and normal to find life meaningless and horrible, and the sooner he accepts the fact the better. As the two carry on their discussion, the world outside of their work site is falling apart into chaos.
A similar cynicism informs the Irish/German co-production “Please Say Something” by David O'Reily, a tale of a dysfunctional marriage between a cat and mouse that uses a raw and abrasive style of computer animation that couldn't be further removed from the likes of SHREK or WALL-E.
Also showing there's more to computer animation than cute kiddie flicks is Croatia's “She Who Measures” by Veljko Popoviç. It presents modern civilization as a procession of consumers pushing shopping carts with TVs strapped to their heads while being led by a clown. Both are quite compelling visually as well as thematically and offer neither laughs, nor hope.
Taken from a series of interviews with people about their first sexual experiences. Sweden's Jonas Odell animates each encounter in a different style reflecting each teller's drastically different attitudes towards the loss of their virginity. Two of the three stories have positive outcomes, but the one that doesn't is almost enough to negate the others.
It's not all darkness and despair, though. Even though it focuses on the petty annoyances of life, Belgian Jonas Geirnaert's “Flatlife” is funny and relatable, and compared to some of the shorts on here, a veritable ray of sunshine. This is also about as close to a traditional "cartoon" as the anthology gets.
British animator Robert Bradbrook recalls memories of his family vacations as a child in “Home Road Movies”, which like "Deconstruction Workers" utilizes some live action elements. The short has a good deal of charm and humor, and is ultimately quite poignant when the narrator realizes just what his father has gone through to make his family happy.
Of course in any anthology, the chances are good that a given viewer isn't going to like every single segment, and that proved to be the case here for me. As much as I admire the work that goes into stop motion animation, I found Turkish animators Burkay Doğan and M. Şakir Arslan's “Average 40 Matches” rather dull and pointless. There's much to admire in the technique of Frenchman Patrick Pleutin's “Bâmiyân”, but his short never really grabbed me. And the bizarre, almost operatic “Tale of the How” by South Africa's The Blackheart Gang just seemed like weird for weird's sake. Still, even the shorts I didn't particularly care for were at least interesting in an artistic sense, and as a whole you really get a sense of how much potential animation has as an artform, and how little of that potential is generally realized. 3 out of 4 stars.

No comments:
Post a Comment
We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.