Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Buried (January 13th and 14th at the Cleveland Cinematheque)

[BURIED screens Thursday January 13th at 8:45pm and Friday January 14th at 7:15pm at the Cleveland Cinematheque. This is a re-post of the review we ran on the Cleveland Movie Blog back in October]


Review by Bob Ignizio

Paul Conroy (Ryan Reynolds) is an independent contractor working in Iraq. After his team is ambushed by insurgents, he wakes up to find himself in a wooden box. Also in the box is a cell phone, a lighter, a pencil, and a flask of hard liquor. For the next ninety minutes, we watch as Paul uses these items to try to escape his predicament. The rest of the world exists only as voices (and later, a video) on Paul's cell phone.

So how do you keep a film interesting when all the audience sees is one dimly lit actor in a tightly confined space? I'm not sure, and apparently neither are director Rodrigo Cortes and writer Chris Sparling. Reynolds does a good job in the film's only true role, but there's just so much one man can do. This is the kind of concept that seems tailor made for a half hour Twilight Zone episode, or better yet, a radio drama if such things still existed. One has to admire the effort to make this gimmick work as a feature film, but eventually it starts to wear thin.

Despite what should be a perfect bit of symbolism (Paul literally “boxed in” with little room to maneuver), the attempts at social commentary about the Iraq war largely fall flat. There's a half hearted effort to portray Paul's kidnappers in shades of gray, but ultimately they come across as little more than stock bad guys. The way in which Paul is treated by the various bureaucrats he contacts over the phone feels contrived and false, too. I'm not taking ideological sides here. I'm just saying Cortes doesn't handle his subtext very well, and it winds up feeling more like an afterthought to pad out the running time than a genuine theme.

The other big problem is Cortes lacks the right sense of rhythm for directing a thriller. There's just no sense of mounting tension and suspense here. What little there is is undermined by artificial moments like the scene where a snake gets into the box with Paul. And then there's the ending. Upbeat, downbeat, ambiguous – any kind of ending is fine as long as it's the right one for the movie in question. Without giving away any spoilers, this doesn't feel like the right ending for this particular movie. 2 ½ out of 4 stars.

No comments:

Post a Comment

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.