Thursday, January 20, 2011

Budrus (January 21 and 23 at the Cleveland Museum of Art)

[BUDRUS screens Friday January 21st at 7 p.m. and Sunday January 23rd at 1:30 p.m. at the Cleveland Museum of Art]

Review by Charles Cassady Jr.

If the first casualty of war is truth, the first casualty of Israeli-Palestinian war is any hope things will ever get getter. I like what Harlan Ellison said, that the only solution he can see is build a wall around the whole Middle East, shut everybody in. Have one locked door. Each year open it and look in and see if Arabs and Jews have figured out a way to not kill each other. If they haven't, lock the door, check back in another year.

If the hopeful documentary BUDRUS, from Mideast-specialty filmmaker Julia Bacha, is any indication, Arab and Jew may actually figure out a way not kill each other after all, and here too a wall is involved. Budrus is a Palestinian mountain village bordering Israel, an opportunity for terrorists to cross over. The Israeli central government literally bulldozes through the "separation barrier," a security-fence project to stop suicide bombers from reaching the West Bank. The fence cuts across Budrus, endangering groves of olive trees that are the town's economic (and spiritual and cultural) foundation. Cameras talk to those on the front lines on both sides, from Israeli border guards to the hero of the piece, Arab family man Ayed Morrar.

Ayed is not comfortable with militant groups such as Hamas and Fatah and their rhetoric, bombs and rock-throwing that let off Palestinian anger but don't lead to anything but grief and rubber bullets. Instead he leads opposition to the fence by applying Gandhi/MLK methods of non-violent resistance against soldiers and construction gangs. His daughter also joins, leading squads of women protesters that seemingly befuddle Israeli troops unaccustomed to assertive Muslim females. An Israeli border guard named Yasmine becomes a favorite target; she joined the border patrols feeling they offered the best chance for advancement for a woman, and now her feminist ideals are tied up in knots by protesting Palestinian ladies who call her out and speaking their own minds, not being thrust forth as human shields.

The non-violent stuff actually catches on. Israeli TV monitors the situation, and soon international peace protesters from South Africa and - most astounding to the Budrus villagers - reconciliation-seeking Jewish activists from Israel show up, joining in solidarity with token representatives of Hamas and Fatah, to thwart the planned barrier. For a lot of the villagers it's the first time they've ever seen a Jew who wasn't carrying a rifle and in uniform, bullying them at a checkpoint. Even so, there's no certainty this won't end up being a violent intifada, making the optimistic conclusion all the more welcome.

Bacha interviews all side and gives them human faces...all but one, the remote officialdom who came up with the fence in the first place. I hate to be a killjoy, but a conspiracy-minded sort might indeed wonder if the Israeli top brass deliberately plotted an untenable fence route, acting the bad cop, as it were, to give both sides something to unite over and win concessions. Maybe they got the idea from THE FANTASTICKS. Or maybe they just saw the same Harlan Ellison rant I did.

Ellison rejected an honorary Cleveland Arts Prize, did you know that? Someday maybe I'll find an excuse to tell why.

No comments:

Post a Comment

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.