Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Black Swan

Director Darren Aronofsky conceived Black Swan as a companion piece to his previous film The Wrestler. Both films center on characters willing to do anything for one moment of success in their respective fields, up to and including dying for it. In this case that character is Nina (Natalie Portman), an unstable ballerina who sees doppelgangers of herself on the subway and engages in a little light self mutilation to cope with stress. Her mother Erica (Barbara Hershey) is a controlling shrew who used to be a ballerina herself, but gave up the profession to have her daughter. Now she drives Nina to succeed, while simultaneously trying to hold her back.

Nina wants the lead in her ballet company's production of Swan Lake. Her director Thomas (Vincent Cassell) tells her that she's perfect for the virginal white swan, but lacks the necessary passion to dance the other part of the dual role, the “evil” black swan. New dancer Lily (Mila Kunis), with her confident and casual sexuality, seems far more in tune with the white swan's double.

Despite constant practice, Nina remains unable to channel any real passion into her dancing. Her director suggests she try masturbating.  No, seriously, I'm not making this up.  She does, only to turn over and find her mom sleeping in a chair. That'll kill the mood. So Nina externalizes her “bad girl” side onto Lily, for whom she also feels some attraction, and slips further into dementia. Black Swan may be a movie about women and female sexuality, but the way it handles this material never lets you forget it was written and directed by men.

Aronofsky tells his story in a visually arresting manner, but sometimes he just seems to be trying too hard. His symbolism is often obvious and clumsy, with nary a frame of film going by without some sort of mirror or other reflective surface to remind us of Nina's dual nature. There's also no missing the film's references to that old Freudian warhorse, the virgin/whore complex. In one scene it gets literally spelled out in red lipstick. On a mirror, to boot.

At least the performances by Portman and Kunis are subtle and layered even when the film isn't, and for all my griping about heavy handed symbolism, there are times when you just want to get swept along by the visuals.  The film does work as trashy, campy fun, but taken as seriously as it clearly wants to be, it's about as deep as a freshman college student who just took his first psychology class.  If all Aronofsky and his writers have to offer us is a message that can be boiled down to, pardon my bluntness, the crazy bitch needs to get laid, I just don't think that's enough. 2 ½ out of 4 stars.

1 comment:

  1. Harsh. Maybe you just need to get laid. Kidding aside, Aronofsky was in waaaaay over his head with the general feminist/female sexuality themes. Typical man.

    Bonus for not calling this a "psycho-sexual thriller."

    ReplyDelete

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.