Review by Bob Ignizio
In For Colored Girls, writer/director Tyler Perry puts his female characters through the ringer, afflicting them with rape, incest, infidelity, spousal abuse, venereal disease, and back-alley abortions. As for the men in the film, they range from mere worthless jackasses to the downright sadistic. I wouldn't go so far as to say the movie means to demonize all men, or even all black men. Many of these guys are shown to have their own mitigating issues. They may not be blameless, but you can at least sympathize with some of them. Still, with the exception of one guy who's practically a saint, this is a fairly one-sided and negative portrayal of the male gender.The movie originates from a stage play that consisted of a series of soliloquies delivered in poetry slam style. The soliloquies are still present in the film version, but Perry connects them together with a traditional narrative storyline. The way he does that, however, stretches credulity. It's just hard to swallow that all these women would be experiencing all these horrible things in such a short span of time, and be so interconnected with each other. Not as ridiculous as the notion in last year's Precious that so much woe could befall one person, but it still feels pretty contrived. That's compounded by Perry's straight-forward directorial style. It works fine in the connecting segments, but when the characters break into monologue it feels jarring and overly affected.
On the plus side, there are a lot of strong performances here. Kimberly Elise as a woman married to an abusive Iraq war vet, Kerry Washington as the social worker married to the only good man in the movie, and Felicia Rashad as a nosy but caring apartment manager are the standouts. Everyone does fine work here, though. Heck, what actor doesn't pull out all the stops when given the chance to do a soliloquy? In the end, though, the performances can't save this movie. I can see how this material might have worked in its original stage play format, but in the transition to film something seems to have been lost. 2 ½ out of 4 stars.
I am extremely against Tyler Perry. I have no reason for this. He just irks me.
ReplyDeleteSounds like a typical Tyler Perry flick. Urban melodrama at its most ham-fisted.
ReplyDelete