Review by Jeff Niesel
If A Film Unfinished, Yael Hersonski’s documentary about a Nazi propaganda film, consisted merely of the footage that was shot in the Warsaw Ghetto just a before its Jewish residents were deported to concentration camps, it would be a compelling feature. But Hersonski has masterfully used the footage to create a story. Relying upon the journals of Jews detained in the ghetto for his narration, Hersonski is able to show not only how much of the footage was staged but also how it inadvertently foreshadowed the impending horrors. “The filmmakers told them to look happy,” writes one man who was present while some of the filming was taking place. Hersonski also interviews living survivors who remember the filming and recovers testimony from a German cameraman who talked about the instructions he was given while making the movie. Hersonski captures the survivors’ reactions as they watch what remains of the unfinished film. Many of the images here are disturbing. We regularly see bodies lying prone on the streets, and in one scene a woman walks in circles. While we can’t hear her, we can see she’s screaming because she’s hungry. This footage has been historically treated as an accurate document of life in the Warsaw Ghetto. Hersonski’s movie completely rejects that notion, exposing the extent to which it was staged to distort our perception of the Third Reich.
No comments:
Post a Comment
We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.