Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Conviction

Review by Eddie Fleisher

In 1983, Kenneth Waters was convicted of murder in Ayer, Massachusetts, and sentenced to life in prison. His sister, Betty Anne, was so convinced of her brother's innocence that she sacrificed much of her own life to go to law school so she could help exonerate him. After finally becoming a lawyer, she teamed up with Barry Scheck of the Innocence Project, and together - thanks to DNA testing and proof of police corruption - they freed Kenneth after 18 years of being wrongly imprisoned. This is the real life story behind the movie Conviction, which stars Hillary Swank as Betty Anne, and Sam Rockwell as Kenneth Waters.

Betty Anne's role is not simple, and Hillary Swank captures her character's complexity well. At first glance, her devotion to her brother seems like some naive, small-town mentality. Not to mention, she doesn't seem like the brightest person to begin with. But, as time progresses, we learn of the bond between the siblings, and the deep loyalty that she has towards Kenneth. We also begin to see that underneath, Betty Anne isn't stupid. She's got a drive and determination so strong, that it's not surprising that she accomplished what she did. During her journey, she suffers a divorce and has to fix a damaged relationship with her sons, who begin to resent her time consuming mission.

Sam Rockwell does a terrific job as Kenneth Waters, a man who's such a screw-up that it's easy to think he may be guilty early on. The film makes sure to show Kenneth as he really was, and not as some perfect angel. He's not always lovable, but at the same time, there's something about him that makes murder seem unlikely. Rockwell's shining moments come towards the end of the film, in Kenneth's emotional exchanges with his sister, and his daughter, who's relationship was severely strained by his imprisonment. Rockwell’s subtleties, such as his facial expressions and mannerisms, help him nail the role.

Swank and Rockwell are aided by a superb supporting cast, especially Minnie Driver, who’s excellent as Betty Anne’s best friend, and Juliette Lewis, who turns in one of her best performances as Kenneth’s trashy ex-girlfriend.

It'd be easy to make this movie a political platform that criticizes our justice system and the corruption of police departments - heck, it’d have every right to do that - but instead, director Tony Goldwyn and writer Pamela Gray make this story more about the people involved, and how their lives were affected by such a tragedy. It’s more about the bond between the Waters siblings, and the lengths they’d go to help each other. An innocent man being locked up for almost 20 years is beyond awful, but Conviction focuses on the remarkable silver lining, and makes you wonder: how far would you go for your loved ones?

2 comments:

  1. You know, I was going to get on my high legal horse and pontificate on my disappointment over the film's refusal to delve into the law enforcement and prosecutorial engine that spat out an unjust fate for Kenneth. But your explanation makes sense.

    I'm still disappointed that Kenneth's sudden death six months after his release wasn't so much as even touched upon, tho.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Uh, thanks for spoiling the ending, Camevil.

    ReplyDelete

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.