Review by Bob Ignizio
Administering discipline is a necessary part of parenting, but sticking your daughter in a lit oven is going a bit far by just about anyone's standards. Apparently the parents of 10 year old Lilith (Jodelle Ferland) never read Dr. Spock, though, because that's exactly what they do. Luckily social worker Emily (RenĂ©e Zellweger) and her friend police detective Barron (Ian McShayne) show up before things get too hot for the little girl. After the rescue, Emily takes a special interest in Lilith, even going so far as to get herself named the girl's guardian. But when everyone Emily knows begins dying under mysterious circumstances, it starts to look as though Lilith’s parents may not have been so crazy after all.
Administering discipline is a necessary part of parenting, but sticking your daughter in a lit oven is going a bit far by just about anyone's standards. Apparently the parents of 10 year old Lilith (Jodelle Ferland) never read Dr. Spock, though, because that's exactly what they do. Luckily social worker Emily (RenĂ©e Zellweger) and her friend police detective Barron (Ian McShayne) show up before things get too hot for the little girl. After the rescue, Emily takes a special interest in Lilith, even going so far as to get herself named the girl's guardian. But when everyone Emily knows begins dying under mysterious circumstances, it starts to look as though Lilith’s parents may not have been so crazy after all.
The biggest problem with Case 39 is that it fails to generate much in the way of suspense or horror. Director Christian Alvart just doesn't know how to deliver a good shock, even blowing the cheap and easy jump scares most of the time. Granted, there's one scene involving hornets that's sure to make the apiphobics in the audience squirm, but that's about it. The script isn't much to write home about, either. It starts out interestingly enough, but eventually devolves into yet another variation on The Bad Seed with a supernatural twist that's handled so poorly that it loses any impact it might have had. 2 out of 4 stars.

Ugh. Utterly forgettable. I was waiting for the ladies after the movie and a guy asked me which movie I had just seen. I had to look at the sign because I couldn't remember the name.
ReplyDeleteThe guy didn't like it much either.
They lost me at the premise. Too bad. Ian McShayne is so badass.
ReplyDelete