Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Carnival of Souls (October 30th and 31st at the Cleveland Cinematheque)

[Carnival of Souls screens October 30th at 8:45 pm and October 31st at 6:30 pm at the Cleveland Cinematheque]

Review by Charles Cassady, Jr.

There's the romantic notion in the creative arts of the "one and done," the lone effort of some painter/playwright/novelist/composer/filmmaker who put everything he or she had into a single masterwork, then didn't accomplish anything else. Jonathan Larson of "Rent" fame almost did that, as did Margaret Mitchell with "Gone With the Wind," Emily Bronte with "Wuthering Heights" and filmmaker Steve Gordon with "Arthur" (let's not count the scroungers who kept finding and publishing all their inferior first-tries and drafts posthumously).



That industrial filmmaker Herk Harvey never made another feature after Carnival of Souls in 1962 earns him a place in that company, even though I'm given to understand the dude tried to get other films, probably remake-sequels or somesuch, off the ground until he died. I'd hate to imagine, say, Carnival of Souls '75: Carnival of Souls Meet the Harlem Globetrotters on Gilligan's Island. Let the crystalline memory of the first film remain unblemished, if only for personal nostalgia's sake. Carnival of Souls was made on a shoestring in Lawrence, Kansas, and, as with George Romero's original Night of the Living Dead, was the work of semi-gifted amateurs (many from U of Kansas) who hadn't even done the proper copyright work. Thus Carnival of Souls plays in heavy rotation in the public-domain realm of syndicated TV hosting slots.

The dialogue-sparse plotline, echoes very much of a super-sized episode of golden-age TV anthology chillers as "One Step Beyond" and, of course, "The Twilight Zone." A pretty young woman (Candace Hilligoss, who also appeared in very little beyond this) walks away from a bad car wreck over a bridge in a river that kills her two passengers. With scattered hints of unbecoming sins in her past, the disoriented heroine seeks employment incongruously as a church organist and drifts through a bleak middle-America environment of glass storefronts, and faceless crowds, an increasingly oppressive atmosphere in which she finds herself repeatedly spooked by phantom figures with corpselike complexions (the chief one portrayed by director Harvey himself). Events creep toward a strange, abandoned lakeside pavilion (a ready-made structure, nothing that the filmmakers had to erect), and while the "surprise" ending is not much a surprise, the impact of the $100,000 film is all mood and ambiance - and perhaps a little bit of childhood good memories at having watched this thing innumerable times on "Super Host."

 It may be a debatable point whether the dreamlike atmosphere that pervades, that made critics start to appreciate and praise the little film after it made its paltry run on the horror-exploitation circuit, is by design or lucky accident of first-timers. Acting and camerawork is certainly off-kilter at times, lyrical and haunting at others, and the beaming, ghost-pale spirit-characters aren't exceptionally scary in and of themselves (in truth, they kinda recall "Grandpa" from "The Munsters").  But, as computer programmers sometimes say, that's not a bug that's "function," and even the flaws in this cheapie have enhanced its legend as a DIY success. And Herk Harvey didn't leave behind any sophomore-slump followups, so there. I am aware that Robert Englund appeared in a 1990s direct-to-video thing, also called Carnival of Souls, of which I have not had the, uh, pleasure of acquaintance. Leave it one-and-done.

No comments:

Post a Comment

We approve all legitimate comments. However, comments that include links to irrelevant commercial websites and/or websites dealing with illegal or inappropriate content will be marked as spam.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.